Why Obama should skip Tavis Smiley's State of the Black Union

Sen. Barack Obama took a lot of heat last year from participants in Tavis Smiley's State of the Black Union annual confab, which was held in Virginia. To be fair, he was a little busy that day...announcing HE WAS RUNNING FOR PRESIDENT!

Some of the folks there were besides themselves, and frankly, were childish about it, even saying that he should have put off his presidential announcement to be there.

Now, almost a year later, he is faced with a similar dilemma.

Tavis has announced that he will hold his State of the Black Union annual talkfest on Feb. 23 in New Orleans, La. This is a huge event attended by thousands each year; broadcast on C-SPAN; and attracts some of the nation's top black activists, politicians and intellectuals.

During his commentary Thursday on the Tom Joyner Morning Show, the most listened to black radio show, Tavis said he's invited the three top candidates, Republican frontrunner, Sen. John McCain of Arizona, and Sens. Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama. He said only one has accepted, and he will wait until tomorrow for the other two to decide.

He didn't say which one decided to attend, but on Friday, Clinton announced that she was attending.

In his commentary, Smiley said he was going to snap on those who don't attend on Tuesday's show, demanding that they own up to black issues and zero in on social justice issues as outlined in the book he edited, "The Covenant with Black America."

Here is my analysis of the situation, and hopefully it will put this presidential campaign and the delicate task of navigating the waters of black politics in perspective.

1. Clinton MUST attend. She led Obama in all of 2007 among black voters by huge margins. But that trend has shifted -dramatically. At best, she's polling at 25% among African Americans. Her acceptance is critical because she needs to capture 30% to 40% of the black to really stop Obama.

The perceived racial slights toward Obama by Clinton campaign surrogates, as well as her husband, former President Bill Clinton, has done significant damage in the black community. His attempts to explain the comments haven't mollified African Americans. Her appearance at the event can help her restore her standing among a vital Democratic constituency, which she will need to turn out en masse if she wins the nomination.

Also, her campaign doesn't have the cash Obama has. She needs any free media. And if Obama shows up, that means all the national media will be there, and the stage is set for her. Tavis said on the air that he would push for the candidates to debate the issues. She's called for more; Obama has only accepted two.

Smart politics on her part, and if I were advising her, no doubt I would tell her to attend.

2. Obama must look forward, not in the past. The Louisiana primary, which he won handily, was on Saturday. Why go back to Louisiana for an event on Feb. 23? That is not to dismiss the needs of people along the Gulf Coast. But the only way he can truly help them is if he wins the nomination and the White House.

Obama needs to be solely focused on Texas and Ohio. Those two mega-states offer a huge bounty of delegates, and he needs to win a large state to move ahead of Clinton. She polls strongly in both states, and they are a huge part of her winning strategy; so much of her time will be spent there in the coming weeks.

All his time must be on the ground. In Texas, he must blanket South Texas because of the Hispanic influence. He didn't do well among Hispanics in California, and he must change that.

There is some hope (no pun intended). When former Dallas Mayor Ron Kirk ran in 2002 for the U.S. Senate, he took 74 percent of South Texas. Yes, an Hispanic was running for governor, but that bodes well for Obama. In Ohio, he must do well among blue collar Democrats. Clinton has owned these low- to middle-income voters, and Obama must score well among them.

If Tavis wanted to have an impact, he should have held his event before Louisiana or before the Mississippi primary. As the saying goes, bad planning on your part doesn't constitute a sense of urgency on mine.

3. He can't be defined again as the black candidate. Some will say he must avoid black folks to be more palatable to whites and Hispanics. I disagree. But you can't deny the reality that he's running for president of the United States and not president of Black America. The week of the South Carolina was all about race, and he knows that is not a winning discussion because of this nation's history. His campaign successfully beat back that issue since South Carolina, winning nearly all-white states like Utah, Idaho, Montana, Minnesota, Delaware, Connecticut, and Nebraska.

Obama is looking to have mass appeal, and showing up in New Orleans at a State of the Black Union event doesn't help him at all in a close race.

4. Send Michelle Obama. What is the purpose of surrogates if you can't make it somewhere? His wife is perfectly suited for this event, and that frees him up to go elsewhere. Plus, he's his top surrogate, and having a female counter your female opponent isn't a bad matchup.

Ask any campaign manager and they will tell you that when it comes to politics, especially in a close race, every minute matters. Candidates are on the phone lines campaigning, trying to raise money, and secure endorsements.

Spending the day with Tavis and his panelists is vital for Clinton. For Obama, time spent courting Latinos in Texas is more important.

African Americans are asking a lot of Obama, the best chance blacks have ever had of one of their own capturing the White House. I often hear folks say they want to know if he is going to back "their" issues. It is no different than how white women are feeling about Clinton. These are indeed historic firsts.

By the way, when people say that black issues are being ignored in the campaign, they are wrong.

The Joint Center for Political and Economic Studies, the nation's most prestigious think tank devoted to African American issues, released a survey showing that the top issues to blacks are the war in Iraq; healthcare; jobs and the economy; and education.

Sounds to me like the candidates have spent a lot of time on those issues, although they could always do more.

As an aside, when I asked my radio listeners on WVON in Chicago if Obama should skip the event, we got 29 calls in two hours, and only two said he should go. And this is a crowd that is normally in agreement with Smiley.

Question of the Day: Do you think Sen. Barack Obama should attend Tavis Smiley's State of the Black Union event in New Orleans on Feb. 23?

Comments

[Lawrence]

Hey Roland,

I completely agree with you. First, I was REALLY ticked off at Tavis at last year's event. They acted like spoiled little kids who hadn't been invited to the party when Barack didn't come. That told me that Tavis and a number of his panel members were either ego driven, or so beholden to the Clintons that they were going to be on the front lines of the negative whisper campaign against Obama. If I were Obama, I would send Michelle and a fruit basket. These State of the Black Union conferences have turned into diatribe fests anyway, where Tavis shills his latest book while the panelists tell us what we already know already.

[nic]

Interesting question!

I disagree w/ Mr. Martin on this one. I think he SHOULD attend.
Clinton will take any chance she gets to present herself as more favorable to Black America. If she shows up & he doesn't, what do you think Tavis will say? Sending Michelle is risky, because of how it might be perceived. I think she would do wonderfully, and probably smash Clinton in any type of debate, but her presence would be seen as Obama blowing them off.

I think he's kind of stuck on this one...he has to go & give some face time...then take the next flight for Houston.

I understand the point about Clinton needing free air time, but in this case, I think Obama has to oblige, lest we have to revisit that degrading question of whether or not he's "black enough" again.

[SJAY]

I think Obama ought to make a brief obligatory appearance, not a lengthy debate. Ask Michelle to attend the majority of the event...
This is the "Little Train that Could" and he's got to keep on chuggin..yes we can, yes we can. Texas is calling and Obama needs to get here as fast as possible to keep that momentum going. Love ya, Tavis, but we got bigger fish to fry right now and time's a wastin'. Let's not sit around talking about it, let's get out and BE about it.

[Kim Johnson]

Obama should not attend this event. I don't know what is wrong with Black America; this State of the Union address to Black America is clearly needed because racism still exists. So with that knowledge, why are people still feeling they need to have Obama prove he cares about the Black community. Obama cannot win as the President of Black America- He needs to show other races that he is the president for everyone. So far his campaign has worked and he should not mess with this success of transcending race. Obviously he cares about the Black community. Focusing on race is not going to help Obama. Especially when he needs to focus on winning more votes in Texas. This is a huge powerplay by Clinton. Obama is losing the Latino and Asian vote because America keeps making him discuss Black/White. If he goes on Tavis's show, Hillary is going to make this even more about Black/White knowing that Obama will be putting the latino vote at risk. Kudos to the suggestion that this is something Michelle Obama should attend. Hillary can't play the victim role with gender.

[KB]

Can't he attend via sattelite to the main event, with Michelle there live for the whole thing??? Can't hate on him behind his back if he's listening.

[RealB.G.]

This is just another incident that is causing me to question Brother Tavis. He has used his radio address on Tom Joyner to be extremely critical of Obama and Clinton. He talks about accountability; however, I have a question for him. He held one of the early debates. He had time to review all the candidates legislative records and hold them accountable for votes or legislation that negatively impacted our community. He did not. Not holding them accountable during a nationally televised debate does not demonstrate service to our community. Now he is demanding that they show up again. How much free media can he get out the message that people don't show up to his events? He should have held them accountable at Howard University. Obama is trying to close the gap against someone with 20 years of name recognition. If I were Obama, I would go with Michelle and Dr. West. Do his part early, allow Dr. West to serve as surrogate and let Michelle close the deal.

[jduncan]

No he should not attend. He needs to concentrate on the other voters that he currently does not have full support from.

[Stacey]

I agree with you wholeheartedly on this one Roland. I think Michelle Obama would be great here, but Barack absolutely has to spend his time in Texas and Ohio and concentrate on winning - and winning alone. Clinton has the advantage of name recognition - especially among Latino voters. It'd be in the best interest of Barack and his campaign staff to have him criss-crossing the two states. I hope Barack or someone senior adviser to his campaign reads this post, and I hope some sensible person working for Tavis Smiley gets through to him.

To be most effective, Barack has to win - thus he must do what it takes to win. He's winning with African Americans, let him court the votes of those where he's not doing so well. That's fair, right?

[Dr, Shabazz]

No he should not attend! Is Tavis CRAZY! Why would he even ask him when he knows that his focus and all of his attention should be on the big states. Tavis is creating havoc for future President Obama. This really ticks me off. It seems as though Tavis is working for H. Clinton! So, my vote is NO! I have a suggestion for Tavis and Obama. Why don't they arrange to have a closed circuit feed or something. That way Sen. Obama can still be in Texas were he needs to be if he is going to when this election. Roland, is there any way you can get these comments to Sen. Obama? I think that this is a tactic with encouragement from the Clinton's to take the momentum from Obama. She (Clinton) can do whatever she wants but she cannot stop a movement!

[SAWilson]

Senator Obama should not attend. I am an African-American who attended the State of the Black Union last year in Hampton, Virginia. Yes the topics of disscussions were pertaining to Afican-Americans and were extremely important for us as a community but that is the point it pertained to only African-Americans. If Senator Obama focuses on being the presidential candidate for Black people he will not be the President of the United States of America. Remember there is a time and place for everything. Now is not the time for Tavis.

[O. Pinyon]

No, I don't think that Senator Obama should attend the event; but, I think it important that he send an envoy to show respect for the participants and in a very subtle manner call the question about the political motives of the host. Tavis Smiley wants to be King Maker of the African American community and he wants to be credentialed to enter the White House on D.C. stopovers. A few weeks ago on Tom Joyner's Show, Smiley made a comment to the effect, don't check out on the Brother, but check the Brother out, referring to Barak Obama, from that point, I had no further use for Mr. Smiley. Besides, isn't Smiley the same one who constantly refers to the Clintons as his dear friends? Lastly, any halfway astute participant in the political arena would not invite any candidate to such an event at this time, if only out of respect for the incredible demands on their time, schedule and focus. Shame on Tavis for letting his ego get the best of him -- again!

[TL]

I totally agree w/ Roland. Obama needs to focus on Texas and Ohio. We're not naive enough to believe that Obama is unaware of Black America's issues or that he doesn't have a plan to address them. The Hispanic vote is extremely important if he's going to win the nomination and general election. Tavis needs to chill out.

[A.D]

I think Tavis is only thinking about himself! He's always talking about Black America, well he need to start by putting the lid back on the barrel and stop being a CRAB! Let Sen.Obama do his thing Tavis and stand down for a minute.Brother!

[Darrell Lodon]

Tavis Smiley is quickly becoming irrelevant to the new movement and a deterrent to The Dream. The new movement is about unity and building bridges between cultures. Tavis and many of his cohorts, live off divisiveness. The audacity of him to issue an ultimatum as if he's Almighty; his voice is at the beginning stages of fading to black. He needs to get down with the get down and use his voice to unite this country instead of create this drama!

Obama should make an appearance out of courteous in route to Texas. He should not attend the entire event, nor engage in a debate at said event. He should say to the crowd, 'I stopped by to let you know I love you!’ Then move on.

I'm,

Darrell London.

[Elliott]

No he should not go. But if Michelle isn't equipped to debate with a seasoned veteran in Clinton, I dont think she should attend either. Let's hope black folk at the State of the Black Union read your blog Roland!

[V. Knox]

I completely agree with you, Roland. SENATOR OBAMA SHOULD NOT GO TO THE TAVIS SMILEY STATE OF THE BLACK UNION. Tavis Smiley is a self promoting blow heart. He has been extremely cruel to Sen. Obama on the Tom Joyner Morning Show and now he wants them to come to his event. Is this what you call ironic behavior?
GO AWAY TAVIS SMILEY!!!!!!!!!!!!

[O. Shaw, Jr.]

I think he (Obama) should go to Texas...as you so well stated...he's running to become President of the United States...not the President of Black America....let's keep our eyes on the prize people....

[Denise]

I agree Totally with you on this Roland....I'm offended that Tavis has the audacity to insist ANY candidate should drop their campaigning to attend his event. The heat is ON and Candidates need to focus their attention, energies and finances on the next primary. I already know both Obama and Clinton ARE committed to addressing issues relative to the African American community.

If Tavis really wants to hold politicians accountable.....have a One-on-One interview with John McCain and discuss why he and other Republican Candidates declined to attend the Presidential Forum held in Sept 07 at Morgan State. I'm sure he will decline....again.

[Ron]

His main situation is to get delegates in Texas and Ohio! He can send his wife or appear via satellite. Travis you are Cool but please remember Obama needs to get ahead in the delegate count. Please don't start tripping out. Stay the course.

[freeeternally]

All of the presidential candidates should attend the SOBU. It perplexes me as an African American woman that we say the candidates need to court the Asian and Hispanic vote, yet not ours? Well that's short sided and foolish, once again voicing that we as part of the fabric of America, our issues, and are votes can be taken for granted. I would like to see all of the candidates stand up and address the issues that effect the poor and disenfranchised from all communities in diverse settings, town halls, reservations, etc. I hope our complacency doesn't come back to haunt us with whom ever is elected because we did and take the opportunity to ask the hard questions that Mr. Smiley has worked so hard to create a venue in order for us to do so.

[Erica]

Thank you for your article. I agree with you Roland. The next stop for Obama should be Texas and Ohio. Tavis needs to get his head out of his butt and grown the hell up. In order for Obama to win, he has to appeal to all americans.

[Kenneth]

I hope Senator Obama doesn't show up. This proves to me why a Black person would never become a U. S. president. Why does Senator Obama has to affirm his blackness? Sometime I wonder who is actually politically enlighten or who is fooling whom.

Genetically, he is blacker than the majority of the so called Blacks in this country. How many of us can state that we have a direct linage to Africa.

Let's keep moving.

[Elliott]

Freeeternally,

You feel like Obama might be taking the black vote for granted...which I can understand your point... but sista, you must see the bigger picture here.

How about this novel idea... we help get him in the white house FIRST..THEN we take him to task on black issues. You game?

[Clarence]

Dear Roland,
You are absolutely correct. Obama should be in Texas "pressing the flesh" if that means missing the State of the Black Union event. Reason why, let's look at the bigger picture here, would anyone rather he attend the event and possibly lose Texas and even the nomination or skip the event, win Texas, and the nomination! I'll take the latter everyday of the week. And although I love Tavis for what he's done, he's just wrong on this one and I hope he realizes that ASAP! Giving a Presidential nominee an ultimatum is generally not a good idea especially when he's got a very good chance to be the first African Amercian President in history!

[V. Knox]

Can somebody please help me with this recollection.........I might be mistaken but What Tavis Smiley present at the Jena 6 Situations, or at the death of the black youth at the correction camp?

Because as I see it with all of his promoting and talk - he should have been front and center. Further, I am an African-American female and Tavis Smiley does not speak for me. He is only front and center at these events, which I am sure generate interesting discussions about the state of Black America, however, right now we need more than a discussion - he has been doing this for a couple of years and all I hear is that his books have hit the New York Times Best Seller List and he ask everyone "to please keep buying because it is the first time this type of book has debuted at the top five". Well. Mr. Smiley this is the first viable African-American Candidate for Presidency EVER AND WE WOULD LIKE FOR HIM TO REPRESENT EVERYONE ELSE AS WELL...HE NEEDS TO BE IN TEXAS....SO GET OVER YOURSELF TAVIS- no one is listening.

[c.brown]

I'm with you Roland, Barack needs to stay focus on running his campain in Texas and Ohio, Hillary and Bill had her chance in the South Carolina primary to impress African Americans and they ended up making an ass out of themselves, so there is not a whole lot Hillary or Bill can tell me at this point..and this ain't no Fairy Tale...Barack Obama will be our next President and will represent Americans of all races...

[Reecie]

Right now Barack is in an incredible position with the electorate. He is getting overwhelming support from black voters and he is gaining fast with white supporters. He does not need to be pigeonholed by people like Tavis Smiley into being the "saviour of the black race". I respect Tavis, but to suggest that Obama OWES HIM anything is ridiculous.

This crabs in a barrell "what can you do for ME" syndrome has hurt our community for long enough. Let Obama do what he has to do to win the nomination and change this country for the better.

[D. King]

While I applaud Tavis' passion for black people and our causes, I think he's a little full of himself on this one. He's coming across as quite arrogant. For example, he keeps telling the TJMS listenership to "be aware, don't be fooled," etc. as if he is the only one who can dissect and analyze the current political picture. I am an educated woman who is more than able to study and understand politics and make an informed decision as to whom I will vote for. While I would hope that Sen. Obama would embrace our community as President, we have to understand that he would be President of all people, not just us. I do, however, believe that, based on his message and vision, he would not turn his back on us once he claims the presidency. To answer this blog's question, though, I say Sen. Obama should NOT go to the State of the Union meeting. I love Tavis, but he is way out of line on this one. Look at the big picture and pull up, Tavis!

[Bea]

I think he should attend because I hold him to the same standard that I hold any other candidate that is not Black...I want to know what you will do for African-Americans specifically. It is not enough to fix problems of the poor because history has proven that these types of campaigns do benefit the poor (but not the African-American poor). The African-American community as a whole is at a deficit and there are things that need to be addressed to help close this gap. I do believe Obama needs to speak to everyone in order to win the nomination and election but is it too much to ask that he show a sign of interest in what matters to Black people. Is attending one event a full week before the primary too much to ask? The geographical proximity to TX makes it very reasonable to drop-in.

If Obama continues to receive a free pass just so we can participate in electing the first Black president than none of us should cry if we receive the same treatment from Obama (if elected) that we received from Bush when the Republicans courted the Black Church in 2000 received the vote and did nothing to help the Black community.

And just to be clear let me add that...I am a highly educated, affluent, happily married to a Black Man, with children, middle-aged African-American woman who has been voting since the age of 18 and actually benefits more personally from Republican Policies. But I believe that this country has an obligation to my people and anyone that I vote for must earn my vote. Obama has not earned it. Let's hope he demonstrates something to earn it between now and March 4th as I live in TX.

[Ingrid Alliman]

I agree, He should not attend. He has bigger things to worry about right now. In due time, he can attend these types of events, but as of Tuesday, Senator Obama needs to focus on the upcoming primary in Ohio and Texas. Perhaps, he can send Mrs.Obama, as she would represent him well!

[Ron Miller]

I think Senator Obama should send his wife. Actually, not him but his campaign should send her. He should focus on his campaign and not fall into the Clinton trap of free press. Mrs Obama is more than capable of representing her husband's campaign.

[Les Jewell]

Roland Your Right!
Tavis is tripping, I respect Mr. Scratchy voice most of the time, but this seems to be personal. Tavis should listen to Dr. West, I'm sure he has broken this whole scenario down to him several times. Tavis tries to make it seem like the entire black community is with him but we are not. I think Barak & Michelle both should skip and not use any surrogates. It's obvious that this man is running for President.
Between now and when The Black Union takes place, all black radio host need to do poll simultaneously with one another just as they did with Jena 6 and allow the community to speak. I guarantee that they will agree that Tavis is wrong, and to be honest he is lucky that Obama hasn't blasted him. What's wrong with this Kappa? Tavis needs to listen to my FRAT, Dr. West.
During the Union Dr. West or another on the panel should respectfully humble Tavis publicly just as he has publicly shot at Obama. Mr. Scratchy should shut up, and sit down.
Lastly Tom Joyner, You have seen this man make all these accusation on Obama, do something, switch Tavis out with Roland. Roland has intelligently represented black people on TV and I'm proud of you brother.
One more thing, Dr. West wrote a best seller called "Race Matters" I think the brother knows what he is talking about when it come to supporting a candidate. Good GOD Yawl, Obama 08

[Thesis]

Obama's trying to be President of the UNITED States of America...Not of Black America. Sorry Tavis! I'm with Roland Martin. By the way Roland, if you see this, you're my dude!!! Keep up the great work on CNN and can't wait to see you in the front aisle as a Sr. Political Analyst on CNN. You definitely have a great grasp on being objective while being subjective...if that makes any sense! lol...All in all, i respect your thoughts and your blog!

Obama '08

[Cheryl Johnson]

I will be able to tell what Tavis's true motives are after the TJMS tomorrow. Has Travis put Obama in a catch -22. Damn if he do, damn if he don't. My question is should Obama miss the state of the union forum or miss the state of Texas? Obama is being accountable for his actions, will Travis do the same in the morning? I truly hope both men can "keep the faith". Both are needed.

[TC]

Mr. Obama's attendance might be perceived as a dis but only if it's protrayed as such by Tavis et al. I don't disagree with sending surrogates to campaign on one's behalf, but that old thing we did growing up in matching our opponent with a family member of the same sex might not work here. I would prefer it if the match up were Michele against Bill. I hope Tavis doesn't make an issue against Barack because he needs to campaign. It would have been better if Tavis had organized the event around the time of the LA voting.

[D.LEWIS]

I feel that Tavis Smiley is jealous of Barak Obama. It seems to me that Tavis wanted to be some type of front runner in the black community and when Obama came around, with this new burst of hope for the people, Tavis took offense. I love the TJMS but Tavis is played out! I'm originally from Texas and there are a lot of people there torn between Barak and Hilary...So Texas is where Barak need to be!

[D.LEWIS]

I feel that Tavis Smiley is jealous of Barak Obama. It seems to me that Tavis wanted to be some type of front runner in the black community and when Obama came around, with this new burst of hope for the people, Tavis took offense. I love the TJMS but Tavis is played out! I'm originally from Texas and there are a lot of people there torn between Barak and Hilary...So Texas is where Barak need to be!

[King Byron]

When I heard Roland and Baisden discuss this issue and basically say Obama should not go, it really got under my skin. What's killing me about this entire Obama movement is how everyone is trying to avoid the PREGNANT ELEPHANT in the room - RACE!!! If a Jewish organization requested him to come to a similar event, to get his stand on issues important to him no one will have a problem. Why isn't the request by Tavis seen as another opportunity for Obama to get more votes. I live in New Orleans, and I am undeicded. If the Lation community calls him to a similar event should he decline also? Tavis is doing right to ask THEM to show up. Imagine if McCain, Huckabee, and Hillary show up and Obama personally doesn't then what? What we fail to realize is that the solution to America's problems will be manifested when the problems that impact Black America are solved.

[TonyaG]

Senator Obama should not attend Tavis Smiley's State of the Black Union event. He has addressed several issues pertaining to Black America. What else would you have him to do? Research and analyze his plan for the country. Visit his website and become informed.

Before Tavis creates the platform to "divide and conquer" , he should consider the cost. I think Tavis just wants to prove a point. Perhaps, that he's significant. We are well aware of that. Tavis, let Obama reserve his energy and fight the OTHER side. I wish Tavis would encourage us to read Obama's plan or perhaps invite him to an interview.

I adore Tavis' commitment to improving the state of Black America. I disagree with his handling of Obama.
Obama has to focus on all of America, not just Black America.

[Sharon]

Why would Tavis put Barack Obama in such a position?!!!. He obviously has other motives or is trying to make a narcisstic point. Be happy for him and support someone who is representing all of America

[truthfighter09]

Why is Tavis, who has never supported Obama trying to start this NOW! I think that Smiley has some serious jealousy issues! As I heard someone say, Clinton is hemorrhaging Blacks. Also, how much of this has to do with Maggie Williams entering into her campaign?

D. Lewis if you're still undecided,then you haven't been READING!

[shelley]

Roland, I fully agree with your article, I mean I think that if anything Mr Obama can give a brief statement via sattelite to open up and then send in his biggest gun Michelle Obama, she is "The Closer" and everyone would love to see her go up against Senator Clinton of the Clinton Machine. I believe this is the best match up solution and the strongest. Senator Obama should not be pulled a million and one ways especially as some proof that he is black enough for us. Why didn't they set it in between the breaks of the major primaries..T S you could have planned it better my brother and if you really wanted all the candidates participation you could have thought about planning it around them better and including them in the process by submitting them with a few optional dates well in advance.

Take Michelle and know that we all will be proud and feel just as represented as if we had Obama himself. Actually I'm more excited about a Hillary vs Michelle match up anyway...Please my brother give that to us ladies! :}

[mike]

I agree with you Roland. Tavis should be a little more empathetic to the position Barack Obama is in with trying to WIN Texas and Ohio. What is Tavis Smiley's MOTIVE??? Why would he want to put someone on "blast" for not attending his event. If Tavis were sincere, I believe he would work to get the technology to have Obama on webcast or live via satellite. And since we are on the point of people proving they are for Black America, let's have Tavis ask Hillary Clinton these questions:
1. Why under her husband, Bill Clinton, there were more Black and Brown men incarcerated and put in prison than under any other president in history.
2. Why did Black people LOSE affirmative action under Bill Clinton?
3. Why did Black and Poor people LOSE welfare under Bill Clinton?
4. Why didn't Bill Clinton do anything while 1 MILLION Black people died in Rwanda???
5. Why is Hillary and Bill Clinton AGAINGT reparations for Black people???
6. Why is Hillary Clinton AGAINST the Government of the United States APOLIGIZING for SLAVERY???

Can you PLEASE Roland get these questions to Hillary or Tavis and have them answer them. Thank you. I would love to hear her response on State of the Black Union.

[DD]

Does Tavis Smiley have some sort of vendetta against Barack Obama? Obama should focus on Texas, Ohio and Maryland and should not go to Tavis' Event....and WHY IS it HIS event? Anyway.....I say Send Michelle Obama - She is huge asset to Obama and can stand her own with Hillary.

Sometimes we are our own worst enemy. Tavis, we see you Brother....Can you just sit back and allow another's light to shine? Your behavior is causing more Division and if you REALLY care about the issues of Black America, chill out and let real change take place. Go on and Vote for Hillary and allow those of us who want to - Vote for BARACK OBAMA.

[Demetria Houston]

Roland,
I agree with you completely that Senator Obama SHOULD NOT GO to Tavis Smiley's event. Tavis has not had anything POSITIVE to say about Senator Obama since this whole thing started, and now I can see where this is coming from. I had no idea that he was so upset about Barack not coming to the meeting last year. Anyway, was Hiliary Clinton there last year? Barack has so many other big things on his plate right now, and the nerve of Tavis to ask him to come there now. Tavis is all about the Clinton's, and if I were Barack considering the negative vibe Tavis is dishing out, I would tell him to kiss it. This is our first chance at a viable candidate, and these so called black leaders are trying their best to kill our chance, how selfish of Tavis!!!!!

[marnita]

Roland is right on this one. I believe that if he can't make a brief stop to the SOBU on the way to Texas, then he must move on. It doesn't mean he doesn't care about black issues. If Tavis really listens to Barack, then he knows he has addressed some problems of the black community; the crack/powder cocaine law, making it retroactive; the disproportionate amount of black males in the penal system, helping them to find jobs once they have served their time; education,giving a $4,000 credit for college, but having to give back to the community to get it; eliminating income tax for the elderly making under 50,000. These have been his proposals. Education is the key because if people are educated, they can get the jobs and healthcare. Aside from the crack/cocaine law and black males in the penal system, some of the issues Tavis wants addressed aren't exclusive to Blacks. All races want healthcare,jobs,a good economy and the war to end. Tom Joyner always says Tavis is not hating on Barack, he just loves black people. That's hard to believe. This idea of divisiveness counters that. Barack can't be a savior for all black people and it is unfair for people to expect him to carry that burden. He is running for President of the UNITED STATES. Tavis sounds like he has his hands in the Clinton's pocket along with Andy Young, John Lewis, Bob Johnson, Magic Johnson and others. That is what is so great about Barack, he is not indebted to anyone. He's not bound to the lobbyists and the status quo of Washington. You would think that of all the criticisms of politicians i.e. how dishonest they are, we would want a fresh face, free from the policies of old in Washington. Maybe Tavis is mad because he REALLY DOES think that Bill Clinton was the first BLACK president.

[Michelle W.]

I have to agree with Roland also. As with most races for anything in this country, black people have to work twice as hard to get half as far. Tavis as a black man should realize that. This is the race for the President of the United States of America! What makes Tavis think this race would be any different. He has no right giving an ultimatum to any candidate much less Sen. Obama. That is not the forum for a presidential debate. His attitude towards this whole thing is very egotistical and divisive. Come on Tavis, it's not just about you!

[K. B. Ellis]

Tavis is anti-anything that is not Black, and I abhor the notions that he promotes. He is division-mongering instigator whose platform is outdated, and anyone with half a brain can see that he has ulterior motives. I live in New Orleans and am offended that Tavis would schedule his meeting during the heat of the campaign. If that weren’t enough, he’s scheduled it in New Orleans AFTER the Louisiana primary. So, on one hand, he wants us to believe he’s doing us a favor in the Gulf Coast region by holding his meeting here, but on the other, he times the meeting when it’s too late for our votes to make a difference. Tavis is quickly becoming a non-entity in my book, and no, Obama should not attend this meeting. I don’t think Black people are so shallow and needy as to require such an asinine move from Obama when he clearly needs to be focusing on the states and delegates he has YET TO WIN. And by the way, what are "Black" issues, anyway. I am Black, and I know thousands of Blacks whose issues are as diverse as our skin colors. Tavis doesn't represent me, but I think Obama would represent me, just as he would represent all Americans. Tom Joyner needs to distance himself from Tavis, or his listeners will further distance themselves from him. (i.e. Steve Harvey Morning Show). I know lots of listeners who have already jumped ship.

[Walter McCrimon]

He should not attend.

[Reggie]

Roland,

You are on target with your comments. We cannot pin Obama down as a "black" candidate because it is not fair to him or all of America. Tavis and Tom have done a ton of good for all of us but we must let Obama appeal to a broader audience. I vote for Michelle Obama to go in his place and Barack to focus on Texas and Ohio to show them that he is the right person for the job. He will help to unite us all!

Or plan B...videoconference in.

[Mary]

Instead of having Senator Obama take precious time out of his schedule to answer questions posed by Tavis Smiley, why doesn't the latter change his forum to "how can African-American's help themselves"? I'd much rather Tavis consider solutions to our own problems instead of forcing others to answer for us. Our communities have so many issues that need addressing, like getting and keeping our children in school, teaching respect for the law so that in years to come, our children can be productive members of society and become involved in our communities. Senator Obama's focus needs to be on the upcoming primaries and not addressing issues that we ourselves can address. We need to start taking responsiblity for our own problems. Senator Obama is already uplifting our communities and showing our children what the possiblities can be, if they get an education and stay in school. While Clinton says she'll be there and that's fine, these problems are our own and we need to address them.

[jean]

Roland you are right, Obama should not go.
Tavis get over it already. Obama 08. Maybe there will be Smiley 2012 since he has so many bright ideas.

[CDB]

I generally agree with Tavis on most issues, however he appears to have taken this situation with Barack Obama much to personally. I am a politically active African American female having done much research on both Barack and Hillary. I don't feel that Barack is the best black candidate, he is the best candidate period. I have every confidence that he will be instrumental in advocating some of our issues, however in order for him to continue to move forward in this race to become the democratic nominee, he must focus on all issues, not just black issues. It is important that he be as visible as possible in Texas and Ohio to try and gain momentum in those states. I agree with Roland that sending Michelle Obama would be an excellent alternative. Prehaps Barack can attend a portion of the event, however expecting him to attend the entire weekend in the middle of a very tight campaign is ill-advised and unrealistic. We need him to become the president and should not be either intentionally or unintentionally putting any roadblocks in his way. I hope that Tavis will reconsider his position and come up with a compromise that will be accecptable for both his event and the Obama campaign.

[W. Wordsworth]

Is this Mr. Smiley's "Covenant" with Black America? Well, I want no part of it! It is abundantly clear to me that Mr. Smiley has been bought by self-interest. What exactly was his price? Was it the fact that Bill Clinton mentioned Mr. Smiley in his book? Is that all it took? It is time for Black America to embrace new and vibrant leaders. I hope that when election comes around, Maxine Waters and all of those old leaders who are against our interests will be voted out of office. It's time for new leadership! When Mr. Smiley refused to name the candidate who had accepted, he might as well have - I am sure most of us knew that it was Senator Clinton. I knew that he was too much of a coward to announce to us that his master had sent him. I agree with Roland, Mr. Obama should not attend - it's a trap!

[GaPeach]

All previous elections, Blacks have asked White politicans what they planned to specifically do for the Black community, now there's a Black presidential candidate and folks think he shouldn't attend a majority black event as to not send a message to white voters. Strange thinking.

Ironically, when he was trying to get Black support last year, Obama attend the Essence Music Festival, with about 98% black attendees, but then he hadn't won any delegates or votes yet. No one suggested that he not attend events where the attendees were 99% white (Iowa, etc.).

Sorry to inform those who live in la-la land, Obama is the black candidate. Sad that so many blacks are still so concerned about what white folks think.

[Coach Hall]

I agree with you Roland. I am a teacher, coach and a mentor in the Atlanta Area. What I see everyday are young African American men looking up to everything except positive role models. When Obama becomes president it gives our children hope. Obama has nothing to gain from SOTU address, will it help him win in Texas or Ohio? Our children have nothing to gain from listening to all the negativity that comes with Tavis Smiley opinions. Thanks Roland for another side/solution to this potential problem.

[Delta Lady]

I totally agree with Roland Martin. Obama needs to focus on the larger states to win in areas where he needs stronger support, he will not win the white house with ONLY BLACK VOTES! He will need the votes of a wide range of voters across many different color lines, and he is proving he can do that, but he does need a boost in TX and OH. I don't think he should attend, and I don't think the mature black voters will really take offense to his absence. He's running for President of the UNITED STATES, not President of Black America.

[warren lee]

i think that tavis needs to stop hating on obama, he should know that it is really important for barack to concentrate on texas and that hillary needs all the free air time she can get as well as try and sure up as much black vote as possible. every informed person knows this fact,i think it's more about tavis' ego,he should be more critical of the republicans that snubbed him at his last forum than trying to call barack out.let's get him in the whitehouse first!

[iman]

I agree with you 100%. For those of you who feel that barack obama doesn't sufficiently address issues affecting the black community I invite you visit his website www.barackobama.com. Barack came to my neighborhood last year (Harlem NYC) and spoke candidly about his plan for this country and about the issues that affect our community. I got to see first hand where this man's mind and heart are and I can tell you that I he not only knows what our problems are, but he feels strongly about addressing them.

It takes more than showing up at a conference for me to believe that your looking out for my best interest as a black person. If we as black people measure someones support, by whether they attend a conference or not, we will be doing ourself a great disservice. Anyone can show up at a conference, but it's what you do when that conference is over that matters. I believe Barack is the only person capable of leading this country in the right direction and Hillary Clinto showing up at a conference, shaking hands and taking pictures with black folks will not change my mind about that one bit.

I find it interesting how we're using Tavis' convention as our measure of support. How many regular black folk do you know that go to this event in the first place? Tavis Smiley is not president of the black community and his opionions don't affect mine. While I respect Tavis' work and dedication to our community, I believe Barack is best served by campaigning and speaking directly to the black folks in Texas and Ohio who can't afford to fly down to LA and attend a conference.

To my knowledge, Tavis is a Hillary supporter. This sounds like a perfect oppourtunity to make him stumble in the last legs of the race. I'm very disturbed by these loyalty test we give each other.

[Lisa Whittington]

Tavis--what you are feeling is snubbed. You are not looking at the big picture. You could mess up this whole thing and America is stuck with another 8 republican years. Tavis, please use your power wisely and don't make the rest of America suffer because of your ego. Mr.Obama, handle your business in Texas and don't mind this foolishness.

[Chi-Town- G]

I agree with you Roland. Tavis feels as if Obama has to prove to him that Obama is the right candidate for President. Who is Tavis to think this way! Black voters all over the country have spoken and came out in record crowds in favor of Obama.

The accountibility that Tavis talks about for a President, should be address to the Black communities. We as a people need to have accountibility and have a collective vote or agenda for the President. Not an agenda that is individually driven like e.g. ( he kiss a black person at the church or he acts like he is black, Bill Clinton).

In closing, I think that Tom Joyner needs to stop allowing Tavis to continue this hateriot on the commentary. If Tavis wants to vote for the Clintons, by all means vote for them, but do not try to convince the Black commmunities otherwise by hating on Obama.

[Chi-Town- G]

I agree with you Roland. Tavis feels as if Obama has to prove to him that Obama is the right candidate for President. Who is Tavis to think this way! Black voters all over the country have spoken and came out in record crowds in favor of Obama.

The accountibility that Tavis talks about for a President, should be address to the Black communities. We as a people need to have accountibility and have a collective vote or agenda for the President. Not an agenda that is individually driven like e.g. ( he kiss a black person at the church or he acts like he is black, Bill Clinton).

In closing, I think that Tom Joyner needs to stop allowing Tavis to continue this hateriot on the commentary. If Tavis wants to vote for the Clintons, by all means vote for them, but do not try to convince the Black commmunities otherwise by hating on Obama.

[DST Lady 13]

I totally agree with Roland Martin. Obama needs to focus on the larger states to win in areas where he needs stronger support, he will not win the white house with ONLY BLACK VOTES! He will need the votes of a wide range of voters across many different color lines, and he is proving he can do that, but he does need a boost in TX and OH. I don't think he should attend, and I don't think the mature black voters will really take offense to his absence. He's running for President of the UNITED STATES, not President of Black America.

[MJackson]

Barack should not attend the SOBU because there is much more important business (like Texas) to attend to. Barack has already responded to, and participated in Tavis' demand for the candidates to participate in a debate on "issues important to black america". Why is Tavis making more demands? Why should Barack be required to come back and give Tavis special attention over and over again? It seems like Tavis is setting Barack up in order to justify his own hostility towards Barack and his support of Hillary. More and more, Tavis is acting like Bill Clinton's surrogate attack dog. Bill Clinton has neutralized himself but he certainly hasn't given up. He can't directly comment and attack. So, he needs a surrogate. Introducing Tavis (the Clinton pit bull) Smiley. Tavis is acting like he's been promised a special place at the Clinton table. Also, these days, Tavis is showing his true colors (and it ain't red, white and blue or red black and green, for that matter). For all his declarations about caring for black america, his affirmations ring hollow now. All those passionate sayings ("you have to love the people to lead the people") are now just empty slogans to me now. As time goes by, it's becoming more and more apparent that Tavis is an egotistical control freak. He certainly knows how to talk the talk. But, when it comes time to walk the walk, he's missing in action. The Jena 6 march. Tavis was silent. The strongest, most viable black candidate for president, ever. Tavis offers hostility and hatred. Things that make you go hmmmmm?

[Sheryl]

I believe that all the candidates should attend The State of Black America (TSOBA. Senator Obama should have attended TSOBA in 2007 and should attend 2008. Black America deserves to see all the candidates on their turf.

drsmithshealthcorner.wordpress.com

[Shae Smith]

I AGREE WITH YOU ROLAND... It makes me furious when anyone who is accomplished and BLACK have to bare the cross of the entire race. And I don't want to make a sweeping generalization - but if more individuuals tht make up the BLACK RACE would demand more of themselves then trailblazers like Obama and Oprah would not have to REPRESENT THE RACE. To Tavis, I have respect for him even though i do not agree with him on some points. He is starting to come across as a rabble rouser dust kicking complainer. Obama doesn't owe us ANYTHING. EVEN if Obama wins I hope "so-called" black leaders don't try to ring the proverbial bell at every racial injustice and expect Obama to "come a runnnin".

Obama is making history in a major way. He has the respect of Black America and middle america white people in Idaho, Delaware, Minnesota,Kansas. Why can't you be black and have respect of white people? Go Obama. Tavis should stick to what he knows television and radio - Obama is GLOBAL. Obama is playing the game on a another level. Let him fight the fight on the level he is on. Let Tavis stay in the trenches and continue to make his own impac.

[AJ]

Obama should not lose focus on winning the presidency. Obama is much more than just a black candidate. This election is much more than that. I hate that Tavis has made this much more than what it needs to be. I want to stress unity but on this issue .. Im riding with Obama.

Let's not miss the final exam because we were planning the after party.

[Tenneille Smart in Hartford, CT]

What a difficult position to be in. I do not think Obama should attend this event for the reasons that Roland mentioned. I think that Michelle is highly capable of handling a spirited debate with Mrs. Clinton. Obama needs to be very careful not to marginalize himself--something the Clintons have so desperately been trying to achieve with all the race-baiting to date. It is important for him to remain a candidate for ALL people, not just black people.

[mercedes]

obama should say "yes i can" and attend, as should clinton and mccain and huckabee. but then again, he appears to be doing well not talking in detail about issues. why start now? he's unvetted -- why did the naton have to hear about resco in a debate instead of through national media -- and too unprepared to hold the job. no record, no detaile dideas that compare to hillary's, and nothing but cliches and platitudes about hope. i have hope -- i go to a black church every sunday and hear much better oratory, so his doesn't faze me. the media have given him a free ride, but if he gets the democratic nomination it will end becase the republicans will shred him. if he thinks bill clinton whipped up on him, he's seen nothing yet. most black americans jumped on the bandwagon because they're starved for a role model and think he's black (black is more than a pheotype, people) while liberal whites get to feel good as they launder their racism through him and feel good that they're supporting a "black" man who is actually biracial and not a descendant of slaves and therefore doesn't confront them by his very presence with that which they tried to destroy. as a middle-class, fourth-generation black college graduate with advanced degrees, i'll be voting for clinton in the pennsylvania primary. barack isn't scratching where i itch -- hillary is.

[Shae Smith]

I AGREE WITH YOU ROLAND... It makes me furious when anyone who is accomplished and BLACK have to bare the cross of the entire race.

At the risk of making a sweeping generalization - African Americans would be better off as a community if we demanded of ourselves - as much as we "demand" of trailblazers like Obama and Oprah. The only reason we expect them to REPRESENT THE RACE is because we don't do it ourselves. The mental slavery of Black People goes on.... we need to stop sticking out hands out and pick up our own individual crosses in our own neighborhoods/professions. The government, police, and entertainers should not have more impact on our lives and community than we do. REALIZE THIS FACT and we far better. BE MORE.

As for Tavis, I have respect for him even though i do not agree with him on some points. At times he comes across as a rabble rouser dust-kicking complainer. Obama doesn't owe us ANYTHING. EVEN if Obama wins I hope "so-called" black leaders don't try to ring the proverbial bell at every racial injustice and expect Obama to "come a runnnin".

Obama is making history in a major way. He has the respect of Black America and middle america white people in Idaho, Delaware, Minnesota,Kansas. Why can't you be black and have respect of white people? Go Obama. Tavis should stick to what he knows television and radio - Obama is GLOBAL. Obama is playing the game on a another level. Let him fight the fight on the level he is on. Let Tavis stay in the trenches and continue to make his own impact. Suggestion, take on 50Cent and his ridiculous statements this would be time better spent for Tavis

HILLARY SUPPORTERS WATCH OUT...
Notice how easy her love of black people is altered by the voting trends. Instead of trying to regain our trust - she dismisses states with large African American voters who have leaned toward Obama dismisising his wins in Lousiana, Alabama and Georgia because of the African American vote. Has Hillary forgotten African American’s used to support her and SOME still do. And to generalize a state based on African American population bolsters the evidence that she a devisive candidate.

As a voter who looked forward to comparing and contrasting her campaign against Obama and making an informed judgement in the voting booth. I MUST say Obama’s campaign is coming across as having MORE INTEGRITY. Even when he is losing, he has never attacked Hillary or dismissed the voters who didn’t support him. I am disappointed that Hillary’s campaign is having such a hard time matching Obama campaigns attempt to compete ABOVE board without attacks and dismissing states as “black”.

[Gina]

I agree with Roland. Sen. Obama SHOULD not attend this event. He has to stay 10 steps ahead of Sen. Clinton and attending this gabfest, which gets nothing done anyway, will not help him at all. His wife, Michelle, will be a great fill in for him, or as others have suggested, he can send a message via satellite and then get back to work. Tavis Smiley does not represent me and I don't know why Tom Joyner continues to allow Mr. Smiley the opportunity to run-down Sen. Obama every time he does one of his "commetaries". Tom is a huge Obama supporter! Cancel his contract, Tom, and give one to Roland Martin!

[Shae Smith]

Field Slave/Obama Supporter:
"I seen a way to freedom and power. C'mon go with me. I figured out a way to the promised land - that place Martin and Malcolm spoke of."

House Slave/Clinton Supporter:
"Massa Clinton been good to us. Get on way from here Obama. You gon cause problem fo us all. Didn't Massa Clinton give you food and shelter all these years. Where you gon take us? You never been nowhere but right here on dis plantation wit us. This fine living. We don't know where you trying to go. They gon kill you. Then how us gon survive?"

[rikyrah]

HELL NO, Obama shouldn’t go to the State of the Black Union.

Last year’s was nothing but a haterade fest against him.

Some tv commentator pointed out that Obama does better when he’s able to get out and connect with the voters. That’s when he moves people. They also noted that’s why Billary wants Obama to debate - to keep him away from the voters.

I can see this lunacy now. Obama, having to ride that fine line, while Hillary gets to spout free one-liners that get cheap cheers.

Make no mistake, this is about turning Obama into the BLACK CANDIDATE.

Don’t ever forget - Black folk were forgotten and expendable by the Clinton campaign, because she had that Hispanic firewall…remember?

But, suddenly, Obama’s gaining in the White vote, specifically pulling away from her with White men, pulling up strong with White women, the Black vote is voting against her like she’s George Bush, and the LOWEST percentage of Hispanic vote Obama received on Super Tuesday was 35%.

That was the LOWEST.

He won HALF of it in Connecticut.
60% in Illinois
40% in Colorado, New Mexico, AND Arizona.

Now, if he matches 40% in Texas, he can win the state.

Billary has also got the memo that more than a few Black folks have decided to sit this one out if she's the nominee.

This Tavis garbage is hateration on steroids. Obama already set out his plan for New Orleans…get to a computer, Tavis, and download it.

[mercedes]

it's hilarious that someone would put obama and slave in the same sentence, when never the twain have met. and anyone seeking a road to "freedom" and "the promised land" shouldn't hold their breath waiting for obama to spell out detailed directions. or is it enough for the pied piper to keep playing? lol! good evening, all.

[Chris]

No, Barack should not attend this event. He has more pressing issues to attend too. I agree with Roland send his wife, she is highly capable and will be a great representative. Secondly, Tavis you have got to do better. Each year you get a bunch a black people to come together for an emotional fix, but nothing really happens after the event. Stop being a laughing stock to the world and do something "totally different" that really brings about change.....Also, leave Barack alone. When he came to Virginia I almost wept just seeing a the crowds, Black, White, Asian, and Latinos coming together to support "A man for Change." After seeing his wife on Larry King I am definitely sure that "they are what's best for this nation"...Love you Tavis, stay focused Bro.

[Chris]

No, Barack should not attend this event. He has more pressing issues to attend too. I agree with Roland send his wife, she is highly capable and will be a great representative. Secondly, Tavis you have got to do better. Each year you get a bunch a black people to come together for an emotional fix, but nothing really happens after the event. Stop being a laughing stock to the world and do something "totally different" that really brings about change.....Also, leave Barack alone. When he came to Virginia I almost wept just seeing a the crowds, Black, White, Asian, and Latinos coming together to support "A man for Change." After seeing his wife on Larry King I am definitely sure that "they are what's best for this nation"...Love you Tavis, stay focused Bro.

[Ang]

I feel that Obama should not attend the State of the Black Union conference reason being we are talked out Tavis wrote a book about the black state I don't see any happening but a bunch of talk that all we do is talk. The time for action is now. We have a person that will change the way america look at us and the way the world will respect us. We have a opportunity for major change. We have to Support Obama in Texas, Ohio and else where I will be very upset if the Clinton got into the white house Black people have to stand together and give our brother a chance to shine

[Trina G.]

Absolutely not! Senator Obama should not attend this forum. I am appauled at Mr. Smiley's conviction that if Obama does not attend, he may not be the candidate for our (black) people. If he did attend, I would have to question if he could be an effective leader and one who makes good judgment/decisions. The reason he is gaining momentum and could eventually win the Democratic nomination is because he is a champion for all people. This does not negate his compassion for finding opportunities and solving issues such as social injustice, health care fiasco and other issues concerning Black America. Besides, I believe Senator Obama has addressed the issues Smiley referred to in his book.

I believe we need to focus on the big picture here..."how do we strategically place the best candidate in a position to win the 2008 Presidental Election?" While I personally believe Senator Obama is the right person for the task, I also believe he should be campaigning his "rear end" off in Texas, Ohio and other upcoming primary states. Besides (another besides), he was just in Louisana. Let's keep moving forward and put this behind us. The last thing America needs is for the media to try to divide/destroy what has taken a lifetime to build, trust in a brilliant man who can lead this country into a new, hopeful, and God-fearing direction; a man that represents every walk of life and every human being in this country, no matter the race.

Hey Tavis, if you really want to make a difference, change Black America forum to another time and/or place, because really, this presidential campaign is not about you, "it's much bigger"!

[Mrs C.]

No Mr. Obama should not attend. And people need to remember one thing, Tavis is not doing all of this for "US". Let's keep it real, Tavis has a personal agenda as well!!!

[Darlean]

Come on Tavis. Give Senator Obama a break. You complained last year when he was not at the State of the Black Union meeting. Remember, he was announcing his candecy for President of the United States. That was a very important day for him. Plus I don't think he intentionally planned to make the announcement to take away from your day. Just think, the first State if the Black Union symposium I drove from Michigan to Washington D.C. And last year I drove From Michigan to Verginia and each time I brought my grandchildren and their friends because I thought it was a very historical event. Remember he can't be everywhere at the same time. You should invite Michell, she speak very well for him.PLEASE! PLEASE! PLEASE! DON'T DEVIDE US NOW!!!

[greg]

I agree with you, Barack should not attend. Black folk should avoid complacency and do their homework on Barack's history before complaining about him not attending. WINNING the nomination is far more important at this time than attending the SOBU.

How could anyone think a Presidential candidate like Barack who is 1.a member of the Congressional Black Caucus 2.worked on the south side of Chicago with ministers and community trying to help the disinfranchised with jobs, training programs etc. for three years3.been a long time member of a church that specifically focuses on uplifting the Black community, suddenly be disinterested in Black issues.

The same Barack who has no hesitation referencing the abolishment of slavery and the civil rights movement when speaking to thousands of Americans during his Presidential campaign speeches. Wake Up People!

Tavis Smiley I highly respect but Barack has ALREADY put in the kind of work suggested in Mr Smiley's TCBA years ago, which in part has lead him to where he is today. The United States of America needs a LEADER. We should be glad a guy with Barack's background has the courage, character and intelligence to care enough to take on such a challenge as the Presidency of the United States to affect change.

Black folks missed the memo.

[greg]

I agree with you, Barack should not attend. Black folk should avoid complacency and do their homework on Barack's history before complaining about him not attending. WINNING the nomination is far more important at this time than attending the SOBU.

How could anyone think a Presidential candidate like Barack who is 1.a member of the Congressional Black Caucus 2.worked on the south side of Chicago with ministers and community trying to help the disinfranchised with jobs, training programs etc. for three years3.been a long time member of a church that specifically focuses on uplifting the Black community, suddenly be disinterested in Black issues.

The same Barack who has no hesitation referencing the abolishment of slavery and the civil rights movement when speaking to thousands of Americans during his Presidential campaign speeches. Wake Up People!

Tavis Smiley I highly respect but Barack has ALREADY put in the kind of work suggested in Mr Smiley's TCBA years ago, which in part has lead him to where he is today. The United States of America needs a LEADER. We should be glad a guy with Barack's background has the courage, character and intelligence to care enough to take on such a challenge as the Presidency of the United States to affect change.

Black folks missed the memo.

[Maurice]

Roland, I Agree with your points 100%... BUT when we move to far away from who we are, who do we become? It's sad, that to this date in time we still can say the "First Black ---" to anything. This election brings to mind, Harriett Tubman, who while leading the escapes from bondage to freedom through the underground railroad, threaten to kill anyone who would give up their tactical position or wanted to turn back!!! It also brings to mind, Jack Johnson, Joe Louis, Sugar Ray Robinson, Jim Brown, and ALI!!! The First ---!!! Let's not forget Thurgood Marshall, Adam Clayton Powell, Martin Luther King Jr., Malcolm X, Jesse Owens and Jackie Robinson. They were not only the first (Ones), they were the RIGHT (Ones)! Being the right (Ones) they endured alot of pain, suffering and disrespect in order for (Others) to have better tomorrows. The (Others) were proud, intellegent, strong, supportive, understanding, proactive, united, loving, gifted, couragous, and unselfish. They didn't always agree but they stood united because what was good for one was good for all.

Sen. Obama, is not only the (One),,, he's the RIGHT (One). AND he understands the "Mission is Bigger than the Man". It's never been just about us, we are really an unselfish people. It's about a vision for this world where everyone is in the Pursuit of Excellence! We are the (Others) and we have a great responsibility to the RIGHT (One). Remember the (Others) must be proud, intellegent, strong, supportive, UNDERSTANDING, proactive, united, loving, gifted, couragous, and unselfish for the RIGHT (One).

By being understanding, we lift him up! By doing what needs to be done, we lift him up! By helping him to be better understood by the ones that don't know him and are afraid to give him their votes, we lift him up! By being engaged in this election process supportively, we lift him up! By not talking negatively against him, we lift him up. By allowing him to execute his campaign strategy, we lift him up!!!

In the end, We Lift Him UP!!! or We Tear Him DOWN!!!

By no means is he perfect. He's just the RIGHT (One) with a vision for the world, not just us but the world! This is most important.

That's why we (The Others) must be there,,, to lift him up.

Don't give up on the MISSION TAVIS---

[Valencia]

This is not rocket science. To coin a phrase by Obama on Tom Joyner Monday morning, Tavis is a sophisticated guy; all he has to do is go to the campaign web site to see his positions laid out on key issues as to pertains to everyone, including African Americans. Check out the full commentary at http://whyblackwomenareangry.blogspot.com/2008/02/tavis-on-obama-is-smiley-throwing.html

Well, done Roland. Well done. Let's stay positive and unified people for cream always rises to the top.

[Ivan]

Agreed. Send Michelle and let Tavis explain himself to her. I'm quickly beginning to understand what's going on with Tavis and members of the CBC. For future positions in her administration, political access, personal gain and profit. These individuals hitched themselves to Clinton's Bandwagon, thinking there was no way Obama would be able to put together a national campaign much less run one as effectively as he has done. First they started the 'Is he Black enough" smear and now that thats failed to stop him they are trying to do as much damage control as possible. Now its going to be 'what has he done for black people?' "What will he do for black people?" "Is he good for black people?" Tavis is going to ruin the SOBU forever with this overt attempt to thwart Obama. It is clear that a number of our black Leaders are seriously out of touch with the masses. And I think they will find this out the hard way during their next election cycle. They've become rich and comfortable leaving their constituents in the position of having to nearly beg for scraps from the government's table, year after year, and are told to call it progress. Instead of the mantle of leadership being passed down from one generation to the next, I fear this time it will necessary to push the old guard aside.

[MRS. L D WATTS]

Roland you are completely correct. I am surprised at Tavis. I thought he was an intelligent man?????????

[Les Jewell]

Well just heard Tavis this morning, He sounds like a poor record that has finally taken its last spin. I think he is now aware that Obama will not be there. Tavis has a lot to learn. He has been very foolish in his assessment of Obama. Look Barak don't owe him anything. I'm proud of Barak, and glad he is brilliant enough to know when someone is pigeonholing him. Go Obama. I really hope Tom Joyner will make some changes to having Tavis on his show. Go away and grow up. You have missed the mission Tavis. Obama 08.

[Betsy White]

No,

Maybe if there was one in Texas or Ohio, looking ahead not behind. Tavis Smiley has really upset me. I always looked at him as a progressive influence in our community. But we all need to remember Willie Lynch. Willie Lynch is very deeply entrenched within our community. We fall victim to it without even knowing this. It is subleminally implanted in our makeup as Black Americans. We are still very young in this country, with White Only water fountains being seen in my life time, so we still have a long way to go. Senator Obama started out not recruiting us as a Black unit to support, he had to prove himself to us as well as the rest of America. Now, he needs us to rally behind him, lets get FIRED UP!! in my lifetime......

[Miss M]

I fully agree with you that it is a must for Senator Clinton to attend Tavis' event, but that Senator Obama should not attend. If he is to win Texas and Ohio, he needs to focus his attention on those areas. I am sure a lot of the TS followers will be unhappy with that and Mr. Smiley himself will probably not be happy, but a man or a candidate has to do what a candidate has to do. Senator Obama needs to stay focused right now. Sending Michelle Obama is an EXCELLENT idea. She can hold her own against Senator Clinton, Tavis Smiley and anyone else on the panel. Go Obama. We are so ready for this.

[Marie]

If the venue does not permit Mr. Obama to attend via satellite, then his campaign should be his top priority. A formal letter from Mr. Obama to Tavis, thanking him for the invitation and explaining why he would not be able to attend, would be appropriate as well.

[New Orleanian/Dillard Grad]

At first I would have to say Obama needs to focus on the big picture. Winning the nomination which means continuing campaigning in those states that has yet to have their primaries. However on the other hand its important for me and my families and those impacted by Hurricane Katrina to continue sheding light on the needs of the Gulf Coast. So any time you can get National media exposure i would have to agree on having all candidates present, BARACK included! Its only a few hours out the day anyway. These candidates rarely spend one day in any given city anyway!

[Carmen G.Turner]

Tavis Smiley, puhlease! Tavis needs to get real and recognize that his only "agenda" is his own. He has no interest in black issues beyond keeping his face on air. Obama is on a mission to unite and better the lives of all Americans regardless of race, creed, color, age, gender or political leaning. Let the man get his job done. Tom Joyner, put a muzzle on this hound!

[jnik]

No. Send Michelle and then do a one-on-one interview on Tavis' PBS show. Maybe do a closed circuit hookup from Houston or Cleveland.

[Oliver]

Mr. Obama should not attend this venue!! I think he should send his wife in his place. After all Mrs. Obama will be the first lady if he becomes president. I thnk this will give the black community a chance to connect with Mrs. Obama and understand her thoughts on the State Of Black America.

[Ms T]

I agree with you Roland!
Just as Senator Clinton sends her husband and reps to events she can't attend. Sen. Obama should send his wife and key reps from his campaign. Senator Obama please recognize the tricks of the enemy even if they are your own skin color...stay focused and stay on track. True supporters will be with you all the way and going to this event will not help him win office and if African Americans believe they are being ignored .... WAKE UP! He can't do a darn thing if he doesn't get into office. Ask yourself this question...is Senator Clinton going to this event to make Obama look bad? She's been doing a good job at bashing lately? Why? because she can't win a vote any other way, pulling the gender and race cards is all she has and she's about to get beat out by a "full house"...the tricks are over. And who's team is Travis really on? Is he really for "Black America"? Doesn't look like it to me, which Master do you really serve?

[Esther]

I agree with you Roland! Obama should not attend. He should focus on the next primary. He has addressed these issues in the past! The one thing I just don’t understand is why we keep talking about the issues. Where is the action!

[Henry LaCroix]

Basically, it seems that a candidate needs all the exposure he or she can get. This seems to be a forum that will be seen by an important segment of the electorate and therefore, he would be negligent to miss the opportunity - it seems that Clinton and McCain will not. He might well be making a statement by not showing up but is that the statement his campaign really needs.

[Derrick G]

I agree with Roland. While I am a huge supporter of Tavis and applaud his devotion to moving Black America forward (we sure need more advocates like him), we must not lose site of the BIG picture. Strategy my brother Tavis, Strategy. Let's get Obama in the White House first, then we can better change all the Black houses across America. Furthermore, we definitely need to appeal to more Latinos right now, so Obama needs to stay on his grind in reaching the Hispanic voter. They are the largest minority and a huge voting block we can not ignore. Senator Barack Obama needs to be seen as a candidate of The People, not just African-Americans. We must not lose sight of the Big Picture.

[Jean]

No,

Travis is all about himself.Too much HATRED!! Obama08.

[Valencia]

To see a response to Tavis' Tuesday, February 12th commentary, visit http://whyblackwomenareangry.blogspot.com/2008/02/tavis-smiley-responds-what-does-it-mean.html. No one was put on blast. Let's begin again - in love. It still wins!

[Kevin]

No, he should not go! Tavis Smiley's is only about ratings because the state of a Black Union is a daily issue and not once a year issues. Plus, is not this the same Tavis Smiley that is backing Billery (Hillery) Clinton? Tavis please get a life and grow up and stop doing the dirty work of others. Barack, remember that you will be the President of all of America and not just Black America!!!!!!!!!!!

Obama '08

[bumpyjonas]

I agree. Why aren't you employed by Obama; this is a good strategy. If he can win Ohio, the nomination might be his to lose. It is going to be tough on Clinton from here on in anyway. Obama has good funding, momentum, and his message is simply better. He might make a lousy President, but that is beside the point. His time is now, and everyone can see that.

[Callie]

What is wrong with Tavis?? I heard him this morning on The Tom Joyner Morning Show and I am very disappointed in his whole view point. Tavis wake up "The Dream" is here and as a black woman it is most refreshing to see our youth black and white come together supporting a candidate based on the issues. These young folks do not come from the experience of Jim Crow and just out and out racism. There experience as blacks and whites are different than ours! Thank Yah!! We are from from asking permission from White people to please address our issues?! I refuse to be a part of a black union that is no more than a 21st century version of "Please Massa I's gone work yo crops jus please let me eat summa yo crumbs"!! Tavis talks the talk but really I think he is just hatin on Barack!

[S roberts]

Roland I agree with you! This is a venue for Hillary and not Obama, and proposing that Michelle attend in his place is an excellent choice.

Don't trip Tavis Black America has enough divisiveness to contend with we don't need your drama too.

Texas and Ohio is more important at this time.

GO OBAMA GO!

[Windy City Watcher]

These comments remind me of The Wiz. You guys are a bunch of easily brainwashed emotional sheep being led down a phoney yellow brick road. The Wiz says "green is in!" Then the next day he declares it "red". Whatever "The Wiz" tells you boob tube watchers is in, you fall right in line. The mainstream media is controlling your mind.

Dig it, during the entire Clinton admin and up until Obama came on the scene black people were crazy about Bill Clinton but you really didn't know the scurrilous truth about him. Just like you really don't know anything about this Obama guy, DO YOU??? Just a bunch of followers whipped into Obama fever, that really need to dig yourselves and learn some history. Somebody is running big time game on you. You're being played like a piano.

OMG Now all of a sudden ya'll can't stand Tavis??? Give me a break! Praising Michelle Obama???? That chick just recently learned how to get her hair done. She's hired a personal shopper and now all of a sudden she's the bomb? Ya'll are tripping! That's right I said it!

[A.C.]

Obama responds to Tavis Smiley's criticism on the Tom Joyner morning show
http://mmslb.eonstreams.com/b/reachmedia/021108/obama.wma

or

See Monday, February 11, 2008 - "Senator Barack Obama"
http://blackamericaweb.com/site.aspx/tjms/missed/index

[TBoi]

I agree with Mr. Martin and reiterate "Bad planning on your part does not constitute urgency on my part." I am from Louisiana and I am satisfied that he is my choice for president. I will not be suaded by his appearance or not during the upcoming event here in New Orleans. What I am concerned about is the continued feeling that he must show up and prove himself to Black folk seemingly out of some misdirected obligation. If he chooses not to show up give the candidate a break. With the momentum he has now, I feel he should continue forging ahead to the next task ahead in the states of Texas and Ohio. I am voting for the candidate of my choice who also happens to be black.

[Lonnie Mathews]

I agree with you Roland, I personally think Tavis Smiley needs to sit down some where and find something to do with his time. I have never really cared for him that much anyway. Mr. Obama really does need to focus on winning the democratic nonination and not running around the country to please Tavis and his agenda. My take is, Hey Travis do your thing and let Obama do his thing. Personally I think a lot of the problems that Tavis speaks about with regards to the Black Community is brought on by ourselves, but that's a topic for another day.

[Kelley M.]

I live in Columbus, Ohio – However, the primary purpose of this response is two-fold; (First) Let me start by saying this, it is paramount for Senator Obama to spend as much time in the State of Ohio as well as the State of Texas as humanly possible if he wants to win the those two primaries. (Secondly) I fully agree with you (Roland) that it is a must for Senator Clinton to attend the upcoming “State of the Black Union annual” in VA.

Again, Senator Obama should not attend this event, but his wife (Michelle Obama) should stand in the gap for him.

Great Blog …. Thanks Roland …

Lastly, I enjoy watching you on CNN …

[B Thompson]

No, he should not attend. Apparently, Tavis cannot see the big picture. He has tunnel vision and can only see his own agenda. Poor planning on Tavis' part heaped on Obama at this critical time in the campaign shows that Tavis is out for Tavis. What a waste if Obama feels obliged to spend the time to satisfy Tavis' ego when these other states are so critical for him at this time.

[HoustonTrip]

Last year, Tavis had one or more of his guests arrive and indicate they had to leave early because of other engagements. That is just what Barack and/or Michelle should do. Get there on time, speak and then announce the need to leave and get to Houston.

[Geli]

The Mississippi Primary is not until March 11. I watched the State of the Black Union and don't recall hearing the take action portion of this discussion.

[Civil Brother]

No disrepect to Tavis, but Dr. King is dead.

Roland:
I agree that Senator Obama should not go to the Tavis Smiley event. Let's be real, if we are fortunate enough to have Obama elected it will be through broadbased support. He cannot appear to be the president of only one segment of the population. His appeal to non Blacks is because of his message of positive change. As I read and listen to him, I believe that the issues he has focused on (the war, education, jobs, etc.) are importannt to a majority of Americans. And many, on the republican side, would like very much to tag Obama as a black candidate in a very devisive way.
After watching Mrs. Obama on larry King Last night, I believe Michelle would do very well as her husbands surragate. With all due respect, if Tavis really wants to know where Obama stands on certain issues, why doesn't he reach out to him on a p